Review of "The Climb:

After reading Into Thin Air, I wanted to hear another viewpoint on the 1996 Everest tragedy, and The Climb delivered exactly that. Boukreev’s detailed, unembellished account of the storm and his rescue efforts felt more accurate and more compelling. It’s a different lens on the same event, and one that ultimately spoke louder to me.

Title/Author:

“The Climb: Tragic Ambitions on Everest” by G. Weston DeWalt and Anatoli Boukreev, narrated by Nelson Runger and Richard M. Davidson

Rating: 

4 of 5 stars (very good)

Review: 

This is the second book I’ve read about the May 1996 disaster on Mount Everest, the storm that killed eight climbers, including the well‑respected Scott Fischer. Like many readers drawn to this event or to mountaineering literature in general, I first read Into Thin Air by Jon Krakauer. Now I’ve experienced another perspective on the tragedy — or more accurately, listened to it, through the audio version of The Climb by Anatoli Boukreev and G. Weston DeWalt.

While Boukerr is often regarded as a hero of that night, Krakauer’s account was far less generous, assigning Boukreev a share of blame for the deaths. Fischer was a guide on Boukreev’s Mountain Madness commercial team, while the Adventure Consultants expedition led by Rob Hall suffered four fatalities — Hall, Andy Harris, Doug Hansen, and Yasuko Namba. Three members of the Indo‑Tibetan Border Police also died on the mountain. With so much loss, it’s understandable that Krakauer sought explanations and accountability.

Listening to The Climb gave me a very different sense of the events leading up to that storm. Boukreev’s account felt more descriptive and more objective. He questioned decisions made by both Hall and Fischer, and he didn’t shy away from criticizing the business of commercial guiding — even though he was part of it. But in this book, he comes across primarily as someone trying to provide an accurate, unembellished description of the conditions on the mountain: the weather, the physical state of the climbers, and the chaos of the storm itself. For me, it offered a clearer, more grounded picture of what happened than Krakauer’s version.

That difference may simply reflect the different objectives each author had. But as a reader and listener, I felt Boukreev delivered a more precise account of what he endured while rescuing Charlotte Fox, Sandy Pittman, and Tim Madsen from certain death — without supplemental oxygen, at over 27,000 feet, in hurricane‑force winds. This review isn’t meant to discredit Krakauer; Into Thin Air is a bestselling and influential book. I just preferred this version, where the details of that rescue come directly from the climber who carried it out.

I also want to highlight the excellent narration. The two narrators brought the story vividly to life. At times it felt as though I were on the mountain myself — resting at Base Camp, fighting the brutal cold, or struggling through the thin air with limited gear and limited strength. Their performance added another layer to the experience and was a major reason I preferred this version as someone who enjoys reading about adventures in the Himalayas.

Link:  The Climb Audiobook by G. Weston DeWalt, Anatoli Boukreev