Showing posts with label American football. Show all posts
Showing posts with label American football. Show all posts

Thursday, July 16, 2026

Review of "Rising Tide"

Randy Roberts and Ed Krzemienski’s Rising Tide traces how Joe Namath and Paul “Bear” Bryant helped transform Alabama football into a national force during the 1960s. Their intertwined stories unfold against a backdrop of resistance to integration and the shifting cultural landscape of the Deep South. It’s a compelling blend of biography, football history, and social context.


Title/Author:

“Rising Tide: Bear Bryant, Joe Namath & Dixie’s Last Quarter” by Randy Roberts & Ed Krzemienski

Rating: 

4 of 5 stars (very good)

Review:  Two legendary figures—Joe Namath and Paul “Bear” Bryant—stand at the center of Rising Tide, Randy Roberts and Ed Krzemienski’s absorbing look at how Alabama became a college football powerhouse in the 1960s. Their parallel stories, set against the state’s fierce resistance to integration, give the book both its narrative drive and historical weight.

The authors write with depth and clarity about both men, offering rich background on Namath and Bryant before their paths converge in 1961, when Namath arrived on campus. Although freshmen were ineligible for varsity play, Namath immediately impressed on the freshman team and soon became the Crimson Tide’s starting quarterback. His tenure—marked by standout performances, a suspension late in the 1963 season, and ultimately an All‑American year capped by a national title in 1964—is covered with nuance. Roberts and Krzemienski also give welcome attention to Namath’s high school career and the intense recruiting battle that brought him to Tuscaloosa.

Bryant’s portrayal is equally strong. While the book offers little on his Texas A&M years or the famed Junction Boys, it delivers vivid stories from his Alabama tenure—most memorably his habit of watching practice from a tower and his rare invitation for Namath to join him there. The authors capture Bryant’s near‑mythic status in Alabama, where his authority and popularity seemed unshakeable as long as the team kept winning.

The book’s most compelling section, in my view, is the detailed account of the lawsuit Bryant and Georgia coach Wally Butts filed against The Saturday Evening Post. After the magazine accused Butts of giving Bryant confidential game information before their 1962 matchup, both men fought back, ultimately winning their cases and damages. The courtroom drama is expertly rendered, and the episode underscores just how deeply Bryant was revered throughout the state.

While the chapters on Alabama’s resistance to integration and the broader Dixie landscape are informative, they lack the depth and freshness of the football‑centered material. Readers new to this history will find value, but those familiar with the era may not encounter much that feels new.

For college football fans, Crimson Tide loyalists, or anyone interested in two of the sport’s defining figures, Rising Tide is an engaging and worthwhile read.

 

Link:  Rising Tide: Bear Bryant, Joe Namath, and Dixie's Last Quarter: Roberts, Randy, Krzemienski, Ed: 9781455526321: Amazon.com: Books

Friday, November 29, 2024

Review of “Stugotz’s Personal Record Book”

As I mention in the review, I picked up this book because of the cover. Usually that doesn’t bode well for me, but not in this case.  Here is my review of “Stugotz’s Personal Record Book.” 


Title/Author:

“Stugotz’s Personal Record Book: The Real Winners and Losers in Sports” by Jon “Stugotz” Weiner with Dan Stanczyk


Rating

5 of 5 stars (excellent)


Review: This book was one of the few times the cover was what got me interested in reading it more than the title, subject or author. The cover has the trophies of the four major team sports, and even though I had never heard of “Stugotz”, I thought that this book by Jon “Stugotz” Weiner would be about championship players and teams in those sports.


That was somewhat correct. Stugotz, whose main occupation is to be the second person on the highly popular sports talk show in South Florida hosted by Dan LeBetard, has some very interesting opinions on the best players and teams in various sports and he’s not afraid to tell you why, even if the reader will strongly disagree, as I did several times. A reader might even think some of his opinions are crazy. 


Here is a small sample of those non-conforming takes: Babe Ruth isn’t one of the 10 best baseball players of all time; Chris Paul is not among the best point guards in NBA history (and while he doesn’t mention John Stockton’s name, he’s not included either since Stugotz says a player must win a championship in order to be great - something I strongly disagree with); and that Clayton Kershaw isn’t that great a pitcher because of his struggles in the postseason. 


If these sound outlandish to a reader, this is what they will get throughout the book. However, keep in mind the general tone of sports talk radio - statements like these are made by hosts and callers all the time. Having not heard his radio show, this review is not based on his on-air performance but instead by what he writes in the book. Reading it like a script for sports talk radio and even wanting to call in to either praise or bash his idea (most chapters have this at the end by a respected sports journalist) is the best way to enjoy this book. Just like what you hear on the air, it’s best to not take this extremely seriously and just enjoy reading it for the entertainment value.


I wish to thank Random House for providing a review copy of the book. The views expressed are strictly my own. 


Link:  https://www.amazon.com/Stugotzs-Personal-Record-Book-Winners/dp/0593734084/ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&qid=&sr= 




Sunday, March 23, 2014

Review of "I Did It My Way"

As a fan of all Minnesota sports teams my entire life, I was naturally excited to pick up a copy of the memoirs of legendary Vikings coach Bud Grant.   I was expecting a lot from this book, and was very happy that it delivered on everything I wanted and then some.  Here is my review of "I Did It My Way." 


Title/Author:
“I Did It My Way: A Remarkable Journey to the Hall of Fame” by Bud Grant and Jim Bruton

Tags:
American Football, Canadian Football, professional, coaching, autobiography, Vikings

Published:
September 1, 2013

Length:
288 pages

Rating: 
5 of 5 stars (outstanding)

Review:
Bud Grant is a legend to Minnesota sports fans, so when I saw that he wrote an autobiography I immediately picked up a copy.  I was hoping to not only read about his time coaching the Vikings, but also more about his time in the Canadian Football League, his playing days and what he has done since coaching. Those were all covered, but there is a lot more to the book than that, and it is some of those stories that make this an outstanding book.

No matter what topic is discussed, Grant writes much like he coached - he stated his view or point, talked about the important aspects to either give credence to the story or explain his opinion, and then moved onto the next topic.  He stated several times during the book that he would not dwell too much on games that were lost or players that left the team because he felt that it did not help to dwell on the mistakes if the team was to move forward.  He wrote the book with that concept in mind, as there is not a lot of reflection on the four Super Bowl losses by the Vikings during his tenure or other tough losses.  Instead, he talks a lot about the great players he coached such as Fran Tarkenton, Chuck Foreman and Alan Page.  Vikings fans who followed the team during this time will recall fondly those players who were the stars of the team’s heyday.

There were several “firsts” that Grant accomplished during his sports career as both a player and a coach that are covered in this book. One of these are becoming the first “hardship” case when he left the University of Minnesota’s basketball team to play professionally for the Minneapolis Lakers.  Many readers may not know that Grant was a fine athlete, excelling in basketball and baseball as well as football. He also talks about the Vikings running the “West Coast” offense in the 1970’s before the San Francisco 49’ers did, giving it that moniker. His writing comes across as prideful yet not boastful when covering these topics.

However, I believed some of the best sections of this book were not about his playing or coaching career.  His account of how his family got through the tough economic times was fascinating reading (I won’t give away too many details of that.) His chapters on animals and the outdoors are also well written.

But the best chapter was chapter 3 when he describes his ordeal when he was caught outside during the famous Armistice Day blizzard of 1940.  An avid hunter and fisherman since he was a young boy, Grant was hunting when the storm suddenly arrived and the tale of what he did to survive that storm and ensure his hunting companions were safe was nothing short of incredible.  That chapter alone makes the book worth the time to read.

This is an outstanding book written by a legendary coach that captures his life in the same manner as he coached his football teams.  It covers many topics and aspects of the man’s life in an even-keeled manner and comes across as sincere, not boastful or regretful.  Readers who are sports fans, especially Minnesota sports fans, will love this book.


Did I skim?
No. 

Pace of the book: 
Very good. The book does follow a true timeline and does not skip much. There are times Grant will go off on a tangent with a related story, but these are infrequent and short – it doesn’t steer off course for too long.

Do I recommend? 
Pro football fans will like this book, especially Minnesota Vikings fans. Also, those who enjoy the outdoors will like Grant’s chapters on hunting and animals in general. Something for many tastes.

Book Format Read:
e-book (Kindle)

Buying Links:


Thursday, November 14, 2013

Review of "Fourth and Long"

With the Minnesota Golden Gophers enjoying a good season, I have been watching more college football this year than I have the past few seasons.  So I decided to pick up this book on four Big Ten football programs and I am glad I did.  Here is my review of "Fourth and Long" by John U. Bacon.



Title/Author:
“Fourth and Long: The Fight for the Soul of College Football” by John U. Bacon

Tags:
Football, American, College

Published:
September 3, 2013

Length:
352 pages

Rating: 
4 1/2 of 5 stars (excellent)

Review:
A book that explores the landscape of college football through four Big Ten schools was reason enough for me to pick up this excellent book by John U. Bacon.  What he did with his unlimited access to the football programs at Penn State, Ohio State, Michigan and Northwestern was chronicle nearly every aspect of the game today.   That includes the good, the bad, the ugly, the greed, the passion and the joy that makes millions of fans care about good ol’ State U. every Saturday in the fall.

Of course, discussion of the Jerry Sandusky scandal at Penn State could not be avoided and Mr. Bacon handles this matter with the proper amount of sensitivity and objectivity.  The main focus on Penn State is the new coach and the players who stayed with the program in 2012 even after the NCAA allowed them to transfer schools without losing a year of eligibility.  Even if the reader is not a Penn State fan or looks upon the school and football program less favorably because of the scandal, he or she cannot help but to be uplifted by the unabated enthusiasm and pride these young men have for their school.

As for Ohio State (or should I say THE Ohio State University), they also have problems of their own since they are also ineligible for postseason bowl games, but they have also hired one of the biggest names in college football coaching, Urban Meyer.  Their season too has some interesting moments and the intensity of the Ohio State – Michigan rivalry is told with interesting anecdotes.

Which leads me to Michigan.  Bacon not only tells of the football team’s comings and goings, but it is through the Michigan athletic program where I believe he is at his best in explaining both the good and bad of college sports.  Good in areas such as fierce loyalty by fans, the lack of public funds used for stadiums (he writes scathing commentary on pro teams who use the threat of leaving to secure public funds for facilities) and the sheer numbers of fans who care.  Bad in areas such as college athletics becoming more corporate and the continuing milking of these loyal fans for more money.  He likens the latter to a frog that is placed in a pot of water and the temperature of the water is very slowly raised until it reaches a boiling point and kills the frog.  He asks the rhetorical questions of when the fans will reach that point.

The fourth program analyzed is Northwestern and this one is very different than the other three.  Bacon does a nice job of illustrating how Northwestern still is able to maintain its strict academic policies and also be competitive in football.  They are the new kids on the block compared to the other three schools, having had many losing seasons until 1995.  How they have dealt with the new found success and the people involved is woven into very interesting tales.

Overall, this book is an excellent accounting of four Big Ten programs, each with their own issues and traditions.  All college football fans should read this book, especially Big Ten fans and that includes fans of the other eight schools in the conference.

Did I skim?
No. 

Pace of the book: 
Very good.  It never seemed to drag or steer off course.   What also helped make this a good read was that Mr. Bacon never stayed too long on the story of one school.  Staying on one too long would make the reader forget what was going on with the other three.  However, he didn’t jump around too much, so it was easy to follow the saga for each school as well.

Do I recommend? 
Yes, especially for Big Ten fans.  But even though the book follows the trials and tribulations of four Big Ten teams, all college football fans should enjoy this one.

Book Format Read:
E-Book (Nook)

Buying Links:



Sunday, November 3, 2013

Short review of "Collision Low Crossers"

Normally a shorter review like this will be reserved for a short story or flash fiction, not a full length book.  However I could not do more than skim this book through several parts.  Therefore I am leaving a shorter review, listed below.  I do wish to thank NetGalley for providing a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Rating: 2 1/2 of 5 stars.  (Okay)

Review:

This book, written by a former member of the New York Jets coaching staff, provides a unique pespective into that life:  the life of an NFL coach.  Everything from play creation to scouting to the combine of prospective draft picks is covered.  The latter was my favorite topic of the book and had a quote from a coach that makes the reader raise his or her eyebrows. Paraphrasing it, this coach felt that with many middle aged white men appraising mostly young black men, it had the feel of a Southern plantation in the pre-Civil War era.

That, however, was the best humor and story telling in this book for my liking.  There are plenty of personal stories, especially about Rex Ryan, but they just felt like pauses in the high stress world of coaching.  The book was a difficult read for me mainly because it is geared for the hard core football person who loves the inside scoop.  If that is you, get this book.  If you are a more casual fan like me who only pays attention on Sunday and Monday night (and the occasional Thusday) then pass on this.

Saturday, August 31, 2013

Review of "The President's Team"

The Army-Navy football game is considered by many to be the best ritvalry in all of sports.   One particular game of this rivalry, 1963, was played under very trying circumstances.  That game, the ups and downs of that year's Navy squad and an account of their most prominent fan of that year, are all portrayed in "The President's Team."


 
Title/Author:
“The President’s Team: The 1963 Army-Navy Game & the Assassination of JFK” by Michael Connelly
Tags: 
Football (American), college, history, military, politics
           
Published:
January 13, 2009
Length:
306 pages
Rating: 
4 of 5 stars – very good
Review:
November 22, 1963 is a date that is etched in every American’s memory.  Whether or not a person was alive to say where he or she was when the news was announced, the date always brings a sad thought or memory at the thought of John F. Kennedy dying in the presidential limousine in Dallas.  Kennedy was a Navy veteran and a huge fan of the Naval Academy football team.   The two are interwoven in Michael Connelly’s book about both the man and the football team.
Connelly interweaves biological information about Kennedy and analysis of the football teams of the Naval Academy of the early 1960’s.  The latter is an important point because while most of the football portion of the book is about Navy’s 1963 season, the information Connelly shares about the team illustrates the bond between the President and the football team.  
The information shared on President Kennedy is not too detailed, but for a book of this nature, with football as the main bond between the two main subjects, it is more than adequate to describe the highlights of his time in office and also of his love for football.  Of course, the famous Kennedy touch football games are given their proper due in this book.
If the reader is more interested in the football than the history or politics, then consider this an excellent source of information about the 1963 Navy football team and its Heisman Trophy winning quarterback Roger Staubach.   The previous two years were the buildup to this season in which ironically, the two losses they suffered were in Dallas.  The connection between that fact and that it was where the assassination took place is made by Connelly in a wonder manner.  Each game of Navy’s 1963 season has its own chapter and recap.  Just like with the Kennedy pieces, the writing is detailed enough for a football fan to enjoy, but not so much so that even non-football fans will enjoy these passages as well.
The book will bring back memories for those readers who were around for the events of that time.   For those who were not (or too young to remember them), readers will get to experience a glimpse of not only a nation in deep mourning for the loss of its leader, but also will get to experience a glimpse of what it was like to be a football player for the Naval Academy at the time.  A very good book that should appeal to readers of many topics.
Did I skim?
No
Did I learn something new? 
Yes.  I did learn a little more about Kennedy’s military career and his heroics, but the bulk of new information I learned was about the Navy football teams of that time.  I knew about Staubach and his fantastic junior year, but I did not realize just how good a complete football team this group of Midshipmen was. 
Pace of the book:
Good – switching between the football and the politics of the time kept the reader involved in both sections.
Positives:   
There are many of them.  The writing style is very good – technical enough to show that the writer was very knowledgeable of the topic, yet in a style that was easy to read.  Those who may not know much about football or Presidential history will be able to read and understand these topics just fine.  
I also liked the format of the game-by-game recap of the 1963 Navy season.  It felt like being a fan who was lucky enough to attend every game of that season in which the last two months darkened an otherwise bright year for the program.
Negatives:
While the book was about Kennedy, I would have liked to have read more about the Army team of 1963 as well.  While yes, Kennedy was first and foremost a Navy fan, he was the commander-in-chief of all the armed forces, so the Cadets at West Point also lost their leader as well and felt the loss as much as the Midshipmen. 
 
Do I recommend?  
Yes, for college football fans and historians as there is good information on both the Army-Navy game and on John F. Kennedy 
Book Format Read:
Ebook (EPUB version on Nook)
Buying Links:
 

Wednesday, July 24, 2013

Review of "Love Thy Rival"

This was a book that I picked up only because it was free, but it was a book that would have been worth paying for as it was a good mix of sports, humor and thoughts on human behavior.
Title/Author:
“Love Thy Rival” by Chad Gibbs
Tags:
Baseball, American Football (Professional), American Football (college), American Football (high school), Basketball (college), Basketball (professional), ice hockey, field hockey, soccer, Yankees, Red Sox, Packers, Bears, Auburn, University of Alabama, Oklahoma, Texas, Duke, University of North Carolina, Canadiens, Maple Leafs, Ohio State, University of Michigan.
Published:
August 18, 2012
Length:
308 pages
Rating: 
4 of 5 stars (very good)
Review:
Author Chad Gibbs travels to many different games to understand why fans behave the way they do when their favorite team is about to face their rivals.   Gibbs is caught up in this himself, as he is a fan of the Auburn Tigers football team and the annual “Iron Bowl” game against the University of Alabama is one of the fierce rivalries he writes about in this book.

While there is description of the history of each rivalry and he does describe (sometimes very briefly, sometimes in depth) the action on the field of each game he attended, the goal of the book is to make the reader stop and think about just what these games are – just games and not as serious as some make them out to be.   
Several examples are given to illustrate this to the reader, the most notable being the Army-Navy college football game.   It has been said by many that this is the best rivalry in all of sports, mainly because of what these players will be doing after the games are done.  Gibbs mentions that as well, and says it best that these young men use the game and the sport in general properly – as a pleasant, temporary diversion from real life. 
Gibbs shares stories from fans of each rivalry to show the various degrees of “hate” each one generates.  It ranges from not much at all (Cubs-Cardinals in baseball) to downright rioting (Celtic FC – Rangers FC in the Scottish Premier League of soccer).   It makes the book a very good study into human behavior, and I enjoyed reading each fan’s perspective.

One other item that deserves mention is that Gibbs tells fans of college football or basketball that they should make an effort to go watch the games of other lesser known sports such as softball, track or field hockey.  The latter sport is one he saw while visiting Ohio State for the Ohio State-Michigan football game, and it showed through his writing that he was moved by the experience.

Overall,”Love Thy Rival” is a very good book on sports, fandom, and human behavior.
Did I skim?
No
Did I learn something new?
Yes.   The rivalries for which I was not familiar with the teams (Sounders-Timbers, Celtic FC – Rangers FC, the high school football game) gave me new insights into those rivalries, the teams and the fans.   The two soccer rivalries were the same sport but very different in intensity and the fans’ attitude toward their fellow fans of the other side.
Pace of the book: 
Very good.  Each chapter is short enough to be easily read, but not too short so that readers who are not familiar with the teams can learn new information.   
Positives:
While the topic was serious because Gibbs was trying to make the reader understand why “hate” is a term often used in rivalries, I thought the humor throughout the book was excellent.  There are far too many jokes and funny passages to list here, but I will share my favorite one here.
While visiting the Texas State Fair before attending the Oklahoma-Texas game, Gibbs decided to try a new culinary treat – fried butter.  To understand how he liked it, here are his thoughts: “Thousands of years from now, when archeologists struggle to explain why our society crumbled, I hope they will uncover this book and learn it was because we began frying butter.”
Negatives:
While I did learn some new things about different rivalries, I would have liked to see more history being told about some of them.  Some are covered well, such as the two basketball rivalries, but more could have been told about the hockey and baseball ones, for example.
I also found a few instances where name references did not make sense.  Here is an example I found in the Cubs-Cardinals chapter.  Gibbs writes about the feelings of “Tabatha” on the rivalry, then in the next paragraph states that his friend Brandi “shares Hannah’s sentiment.”  Problem is that there was no “Hannah” in that chapter.   Only Tabatha, Brandi and Mike are mentioned as friends who shared an opinion.  Took me the whole chapter to figure out there was no “Hannah.”
Do I recommend? 
Yes.  A fan of nearly any sport will find his or her favorite one here, and a good rivalry in that sport.
Book Format Read:
EBook (Kindle)
Buying Links:
(Note: as of the date of posting, July 24, 2013, this book is free on Amazon)
http://www.amazon.com/Love-Thy-Rival-Rivalries-ebook/dp/B0091GVINW/ref=sr_1_1?s=digital-text&ie=UTF8&qid=1374715567&sr=1-1&keywords=love+thy+rival

Tuesday, May 21, 2013

Review of "Johnson and Johnson"



Title/Author:

“Johnson and Johnson: A Short Story about Athletics and Academics in College Sports” by Larry LaForge

 

Sport: 

College Football (American)

 

Genre:

Fiction, sports, American football, college, ethics, academics            

 

Published:

August 19, 2012

 

Length:

36 pages

 

Rating: 

3 1/2 of 5 stars – good

 

Review:

Southeast State University’s football team has risen to one of the powerhouses of college football under the tenure of Coach Brack Johnson.  This season looks to be one of the finest as the school is highly ranked in the polls.   All the money that the university has invested in the program with top-notch facilities seems to be paying off. 

Professor Carson Johnson is a rising star in his own right.  On the fast track to tenure, he notices a peculiar trend in the grades and scholastic work of the team’s All-American quarterback.  He does what he believes is the right thing and notifies the dean of academics.  Could this really be happening?

Larry LaForge has addressed this ethical dilemma that is faced by many schools in this era of college football.   This is a short story that alternates the viewpoints of the coach and the professor. The center of the controversy is the team’s star quarterback, Stan Rogers.   Rogers does suffer an injury during the season, but at the time, it is discovered that his academic record shows good grades for work done outside class, but poor grades for in-class work. This creates an ethical dilemma for both the coach and the professor as neither wants the school to appear to be “soft” on academics, but at the same time, needs the quarterback to play.  

The story does take an interesting turn on this issue as Rogers is held out due to his injury, even when it has healed, so this can be addressed.  Each time the story is told in one viewpoint, the section ends with a hint of what is about to happen.   However, this is never spelled out in that next section.   The reader doesn’t really get to experience what the ultimate decision will be.  Instead, the reader will have to draw his or her own conclusion based on the progression of SSU’s season and the action of the academic board.  

 It is a good story that is very relevant for the topic.   It could use a little more substance and character development for the quarterback and the athletic director.  It does have a nice touch with the alternating viewpoints as the reader does understand the issues each man does face.  All in all, a decent short read that college football fans will enjoy.

_________________________________________________________________ 
Did I skim?

No

 
Did I feel connected to the characters? 

Yes.  I especially felt the pain of Coach Brack Johnson, as coaching is a very tenuous occupation at best, and this new revelation made the coach engage with a very hard conversation with his family on what the proper choice should be.  

 
Pace of the story:

Good – switching between the coach and the professor was important with this theme and both sides kept the story moving forward.

 
Positives:   

Both sides of the issue were addressed in the same amount of detail, and the arguments were presented fairly.  This book did not preach one way or the other about the issue – it simply painted a picture of the troubles facing both coach and professor.

 

Negatives:

The final outcome could be presented in a more clear and concise fashion.  I did re-read the last two sections before the epiloge to ensure I understood the entire picture.  For a short story, I found that a bit unsettling, as most short stories will be sharper.   This is not to say that the reader will be left without a conclusion – he or she just has to draw that conclusion on his or her own.

 

Do I recommend?  

Yes, for college football fans or readers who like ethical issues in the book.  

 

Book Format Read: ebook (Kindle)

 

Author Media Links:

http://www.facebook.com/LarryLaForgeStories