Monday, July 14, 2025

Review of "Black Noon"

This is one of the very few books I have purchased since launching this book review site, mainly because it was published just after I started writing and it was not available in digital format at any library.  No problem - while it's been awhile since I bought the book, it is still a great book for racing fans. 


Title/Author:Black Noon: The Year They Stopped the Indy 500” by Art Garner

Rating: 5 of 5 stars (excellent)

Review:  The 1964 Indianapolis 500 was not remembered because one of the most popular and successful drivers of this race, A. J. Foyt was the winner.  It was not remembered because Foyt won driving a roadster, a car that was becoming less popular in favor of rear-engine models such as Lotus.  No, it is remembered because of the tragedy that took place on the second lap in which two drivers, Dave MacDonald and Eddie Sachs, were killed in a fiery crash that is still being discussed today more than 60 years after it happened.

Author Art Garner, a well-respected motorsports writer, does a great job of covering everything from the cars to the drivers (not just MacDonald and Sachs) to the owners and tire company CEOs to break down not only what happened on that fateful Memorial Day race, but also complete research and writing about so many factors taking place before the race.

There are three main sections to the book.  The first one focused on many personalities involved in racing at that time.  Of course, Sachs and MacDonald have extensive write ups of their lives and racing careers, but there is other great information on the personalities mentioned above.  Mickey Thompson, who was the owner of rear engine style cars and who hired MacDonald as a driver, is one example of a person whose story is well covered and well written by Garner. His coverage of the competition for use of tires between Firestone and Goodyear is also worthy of mention here.

The second section of the book focused on the month of May 1964 before the race takes place.  The inside look at Gasoline Alley is fascinating. Garner’s writing about events such as the first day of qualifying in which the pole sitter will be determined, the test rookie drivers must pass before being allowed to attempt to qualify and Moving Day, in which the drivers who are in the lower places may get bumped by faster cars on that last day of qualifying, was outstanding.  As one who is a casual fan of the Indy Car series, this information on what takes place in Indianapolis in May was quite fascinating.

The third section is about the race itself and its aftermath.  It is surprising that the writing about the actual accident and fires that killed the two drivers is more matter-of-fact than emotional and that is very good.  Garner saves the emotional aspects for later and he again writes about nearly everyone who would comment.  Of course, the two widows were covered, but the reactions of other drivers, crew members and others at the track was what truly made the tragedy of this event even more poignant.  Even Foyt, when accepting his congratulations in Victory Lane, is subdued when he finds out the news about Sachs and MacDonald.

Art Garner is one of the best motorsports authors I have read, and even though this book has been out for 11 years, it’s still a great read for motorsports fans about one of the most tragic days in racing.

Link:  https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00GET19G0/ref=x_gr_bb_kindle?caller=Goodreads&tag=x_gr_bb_kindle-20

No comments:

Post a Comment