Showing posts with label Rugby. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rugby. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 12, 2014

Guest review: "Playing the Enemy"

Through the wonder of social media and blogs, I have discovered another book review site that like this one, aims to review books on many different sports and introduce readers to them.  One of these bloggers from the United Kingdom, Aiden Williams, has been kind enough to allow me to share some his reviews here. Keeping in mind the goal of increasing the variety of sports portrayed here, here is Aiden's review of "Playing the Enemy", a book on rugby and Nelson Mandela that inspired the movie "Invictis."


Rugby enthusiast or not, there won’t be many people who don’t instantly recognise iconic the cover image of the moment Nelson Mandela, dressed in a Springbok jersey, handed the Rugby World Cup to the imposingly tall, blonde Afrikaner Francois Pienaar. It’s an image that has come to symbolise the moment that South Africa really began to become the Rainbow Nation. The moment that Mandela’s forgiveness manifested itself in such a public and heart winning way. The moment that appealed to the Afrikaner’s hearts rather than their minds.
John Carlin was the South African correspondent for the Telegraph through the turbulent end to apartheid, Mandela’s release, the first free elections and of course the 1995 Rugby World Cup. In that time he developed not only as deep an understanding of the troubled nation and is people as a foreign correspondent could, but also got to know Mandela and the thought processes which lead the great man to that symbolic act on the Ellis Park turf.
Rugby was the Afrikaner sport, a sport where the non whites of apartheid South Africa would actively support the opposition over the hated Springboks. The green jersey and the Springbok name and symbol itself were emblems of the regime hated by the oppressed majority. But Mandela saw it as the vehicle to win over his former oppressors and in the World Cup, his chance came to show his forgiveness and unite a nation.
Mandela had long taken an approach of wooing those who held him captive; learning their ways, their passions, their language. He soon learned that Rugby held the key to the Afrikaner’s emotions, and the sporting boycott which prevented international competition was hurting them deeply. Carlin’s engaging book charts the political evolution in South Africa through the tumultuous years from Mandela’s imprisonment and release. The country’s future hung in the balance through this time with the threat of civil war ever present, and a fearful white minority seeking solace in their one true passion: Rugby. Carlin weaves this political mess into a compelling tale with Rugby at its core along with interviews aplenty with both oppressed and oppressor alike, all the while against the backdrop of the approaching Rugby World Cup and all that it meant to the country.
The interactions between President and players both before and during the World Cup make for very interesting reading, as Mandela urged “his boys” to take their opportunity to push the country further along the road to integration on the back of the political prefabricating. The players bought into his vision and as they progressed through an ultimately successful World Cup, the story reaches its iconic conclusion, and the rest is, as they say, history.
The book was also the basis for the 2009 film Invictus, and in both formats the story is well told, but in the book form, the greater detail, depth, insight and context Carlin is able to provide makes for a great read for both sports fans and non sports fans alike.
Links:
The Sports Book Review blog:  http://thesportsbookreview.com/ 
For more on this review:  http://thesportsbookreview.com/2013/12/18/playing-the-enemy-nelson-mandela-and-the-game-that-made-a-nation-john-carlin/#more-61  

Thursday, June 27, 2013

Review of A Devilsh Pastime

This book was a history lesson.  But unlike the history lessons back in school, this one was actually FUN to learn!   I wish to thank the author for providing a copy in exchange for an honest review.


Title/Author:

“A Devilish Pastime: A History of Football in All Its Forms” by Graham Hughes

Genre:
 
Football (American), Football (Canadian), Football (Australian) Soccer, Rugby, Gaelic, History, Professional, College, Amateur.

Published:

April 24, 2012

Length:

441 pages

Rating:

3 ½ of 5 stars (good)

Review

When a sports fan hears the word “football”, different images come to mind depending on where that person lives and which games he or she follows.   This book on the history of all types of “football” will have some appeal to these fans - no matter what type of “football” is meant.

Each type of football is covered in this book from its beginnings as a club sport, social gathering or a group of men who want to let off a little steam.   Whether it is soccer from the English school systems, American football at Ivy League schools, or any other piece of history that is associated with a game that relies on advancing field position and kicking, this book covers it.

Painstaking detail and research was undertaken for this book as nothing is left uncovered.   Fans of a particular type of game will find little-known gems about it, and will be left impressed with the wide range of topics covered.   Even if the reader is not a fan of a particular type of game, just some of the historical context will be worth the time it takes to read.

This book is best read with a mindset of wanting to learn history about these games.   If the reader is looking to learn about a new sport, this isn’t the book to do it.  This is explained further later in this review.   I picked up the book hoping to do just that for games like Gaelic football and was taken aback when I could not find any basic descriptions.   However, after realizing that this book would not contain that type of material, I went back and re-read those chapters with the mindset of reading a history book.   This made the book a more pleasant and interesting read.


If for no other reason, Mr. Hughes deserves kudos for the fantastic research on each type of football so that fans of each kind can learn something new about the history of their favorite game.


Did I skim?

No

Did I learn anything new?

Yes – too much to list here!   I was very intrigued by the concept of “masculine Christianity for the basis of acceptance of the games by the Church and also behind the justification of why some otherwise God-fearing men would participate in such brutal games.  This included soccer, rugby, Gaelic football, and American football.

If I had to specify one item that I learned that was very surprising it would be that some believe that American football began as a combination of soccer and rugby.   There are so little soccer elements in American football that it seems hard to believe that scholars believed this.

Pace of the book: 

Somewhat slow, as I re-read some passages because I was not familiar with either the English history described in the early chapters or some of the football games described such as Gaelic.  However, the pace did pick up for me when I read chapters on the games that were more familiar to me.

Positives:

Outstanding research makes this book a good read.   Every aspect of the games is covered, even in the sections that are shorter such as Canadian football.  Each game’s history, players, leagues, clubs, rule changes, social significance and outlook for the future.

Negatives:

This is not a book to become familiar with a sport that the reader does not have prior knowledge.  A reader will not learn the basics for soccer, rugby, or other types of football.  There are references to rules and some explanation of items such as player formations.   But for the basic “what is this game like” reference for a newcomer – it won’t be listed here.  

Do I recommend?

Yes, if you enjoy any type of football game, the section that describes its history will be a good read.  

 Book Format Read:

Ebook (Kindle)

Author Media Links:


Buying links: