Sunday, April 6, 2025

Review of “The Greatest Summer in Baseball History”

Continuing with my baseball theme to start the new season, this was an audiobook I started on the bus trip back from the Mets home opener and finished a couple days later. Title is a little over the top, but the book is solid. 


Title/Author: The Greatest Summer in Baseball History” by John Rosenberg, narrated by Barry Abrams


Rating: 4 of 5 stars (very good)

Review: 1973 was an eventful year in both baseball and America. For the latter, several important events that would affect the nation took place. The withdrawal of American troops in Vietnam, the Watergate hearings, and the Roe v. Wade Supreme Court decision were among the most notable of these. In baseball, the New York Yankees were purchased by a Cleveland shipping company owner named George Steinbrenner, a legendary player played his last season while another chased a hallowed record and a team that frequently fought amongst itself was trying to repeat as champions. That is the setting for this book by John Rosengren. 

Having listened to the audio version, the narration by Barry Abrams is definitely one of the strengths of this book. His telling of some of the major stories in both America and baseball was excellent. Whichever topic was discussed, Abrams did so in a no-nonsense manner that came across much like the news anchors at that time (though non of them were ever mentioned in the book).

The title seems a little hyperbolic as while there were some excellent storylines in that 1973 baseball season, they didn’t feel to be so much better than other years. To his credit, Rosenberg doesn’t compare them to big stories in other years. He sticks with a few topics and covers them thoroughly. These would be the ending of Willie Mays’ career with the New York Mets, Hank Aaron’s pursuit of the all time home run record of 714 by Babe Ruth, the introduction of the designated hitter in the American with a focus on Orlando Cepeda of the Boston Red Sox, and the new Yankee owner who immediately let it be known it was his way or else.

On this last topic, this was the best mix of sports and social or political events of a year or era that I have read in a book of this type. Steinbrenner’s eventual conviction of illegal campaign contributions, especially to President Nixon’s 1972 re-election bid, tied in nicely with the writing on that summer’s Watergate hearings. While not quite as easily done, there are good connections between baseball and these events throughout the book.

As with any book on a baseball season, this climaxes with the World Series. The Mets and the Oakland Athletics played an exciting seven game series won by Oakland to give them back to back championships. The many storylines made by the Athletics, their star Reggie Jackson, and their universally disliked owner Charlie Finley are covered well, as was the unbelievable comeback by the Mets who were left for dead in August only to win the National League East title, then upset the Cincinnati Reds in the NLCS. Of course, the Willie Mays saga is included and overall, the coverage of the baseball is very good, even if it is a bit repetitive on some facts and descriptions. 

Any reader who enjoys books on certain years or seasons in baseball with plenty of social or political commentary will want to check this book out. Highly recommend the audio version. 

Link: https://www.audible.com/pd/The-Greatest-Summer-in-Baseball-History-Audiobook/B0C2W37Z93?eac_link=SMHsVJ6gcDX2&ref=web_search_eac_asin_1&eac_selected_type=asin&eac_selected=B0C2W37Z93&qid=X1m21vL1JG&eac_id=141-2071635-4315628_X1m21vL1JG&sr=1-1 


Saturday, April 5, 2025

Review of "One More for the White Rat"

Continuing my baseball theme for the start of the 2025 season, this was a very quick and enjoyable read about the 1987 St. Louis Cardinals.  Admittedly, I mainly wanted to read this book's last chapter on the World Series that year - I explain why at the end of the review.

Title/Author: One More for the White Rat: The 1987 St. Louis Cardinals Chase the Pennant” by Doug Feldman

Rating: 5 of 5 stars (excellent)

Review: The St. Louis Cardinals are one of the most successful franchises in Major League Baseball.  They have won the World Series 11 times, second only to the New York Yankees.  They have won the National League (NL) title a total of 19 times, third behind the Brooklyn/Los Angeles Dodgers and New York/San Francisco Giants.  One of those years that they won the NL pennant but not the World Series was 1987 and their season that year is captured in this book by Doug Feldman.

Sometimes a book that describes one particular year or season for a sports team will not only discuss the team and its play on the field, but will also discuss political and social issues of that year.  Sometimes that enhances the book’s theme, sometimes it will distract the reader from it.  In the case of this book, it’s neither – Feldman very rarely mentions anything aside from baseball.  If there is something aside from the Cardinals, their players or their opponents, it’s very brief.  An example is the stock market crash of October 19 of that year.  Feldman just wrote about it in one sentence, then went back to the main subject, that year’s World Series between the Cardinals and the Minnesota Twins.

Sticking with baseball information throughout the book was a good decision by Feldman as his writing about the Cardinals was excellent.  A reader will learn about just about every player on that team.  While it would be expected to have information on stars like Ozzie Smith, Willie McGee and John Tudor, it was also very good to read about younger players who were up and coming such as Danny Cox or veterans who were important to the team but didn’t get a lot of playing time such as Tom Lawless.  Name just about any player on that Cardinals team and chances are a reader will find something about him.

Of course, given the nickname of the team’s manager, Whitey Herzog, is in the title of the book (“the White Rat”) there is plenty to learn about him as well. Herzog had the reputation of having the Cardinals play “small ball” and steal a lot of bases, after having previously been the manager of the Texas Rangers, California Angels, and Kansas City Royals.  It was the latter team where he had his first taste of success, but Herzog’s story in the book really begins not when he started with the Cardinals, but when the lost to Herzog’s former team (Royals) in the 1985 World Series.  This shows how focused the book is on the 1987 team as that is when the drive for their 1987 success started. 

While overall the book is excellent and I enjoyed the whole story, I should add a disclaimer that as a Twins fan, my favorite chapter was about the 1987 World Series, where the Twins defeated the Cardinals 4 games to 3 – it was the first World Series in which the home team won every game.

I wish to thank University of Nebraska Press for providing a review copy of the book. The opinions expressed in this review are strictly my own.  

Link: https://www.amazon.com/One-More-White-Rat-Cardinals/dp/1496241401/ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0